# Reviewer Challenge Templates

Use these templates to challenge records with public source evidence. A challenge is not an accusation that a record is false; it is a structured request to repair, narrow, qualify, or preserve the record based on source support.

## Source Locator Challenge

- Record ID:
- Source URL reviewed:
- Current locator:
- Problem:
- Stronger locator or proposed action:

## Category Challenge

- Record ID:
- Source wording:
- Current category:
- Why category may be too broad or unsupported:
- Proposed category or limiting note:

## Affected-Community Label Challenge

- Record ID:
- Source wording:
- Current affected-community label:
- Label concern:
- Proposed label, removal, or qualifier:

## Date Precision Challenge

- Record ID:
- Source date field or item date:
- Current stored date and precision:
- Concern:
- Proposed date precision:

## Response-Depth Challenge

- Record ID:
- Source response text:
- Current response-depth label:
- Concern:
- Proposed response-depth label or wording:

## Rationale Specificity Challenge

- Record ID:
- Rationale field:
- Current rationale:
- Source-specific concern:
- Proposed source-bounded rationale:

## Inclusion Challenge

- Record ID:
- Public source reviewed:
- Inclusion concern:
- Proposed keep, remove, or qualify outcome:

## Counterevidence Challenge

- Record ID:
- Counterevidence URL:
- Field affected:
- How the counterevidence narrows, updates, or contradicts the current record:
- Proposed correction:

## Evidence Rules

Challenges should include a public source URL and field-specific proposed wording. Private assertions, social media-only claims, unsupported inferences, and broad institutional judgments are not enough.