{
  "id": "source_family_certification_review_001",
  "review_batch_id": "source_family_review_001",
  "label": "Source-family certification review 001",
  "standard_version": "certification_rules_v1",
  "generated_at": "2026-06-17",
  "status": "bounded_internal_source_to_record_review",
  "method": "Manual source-to-record review of two university-statement records selected from the non-ED awaiting-review lane. Certification is applied only when every gate passes; one reviewed record is kept not certified because a stored affected-community label is broader than the source text verified in this wave.",
  "public_claim_limit": "This artifact is internal source-to-record review. It must not be described as third-party review, external validation, endorsement, ranking, prevalence measurement, safety scoring, severity scoring, or legal finding.",
  "source_family_counts": {
    "university_statement": 2
  },
  "status_counts": {
    "certified": 1,
    "not_certified": 1
  },
  "records": [
    {
      "event_id": "evt_2024_0002",
      "school_id": "drexel_university",
      "source_family": "university_statement",
      "certification_status": "certified",
      "certification_basis": "source_family_review_001_internal_source_to_record_review",
      "not_certified_reason": null,
      "blocked_reason": null,
      "source_locator": {
        "locator_type": "public_statement",
        "source_id": "src_drexel_2024_08_02_resolution",
        "publisher": "Drexel University",
        "item_title": "Drexel Reaches Voluntary Resolution Agreement on Title VI Investigation",
        "published_date": "2024-08-02",
        "locator": "Drexel University Office of the President statement titled \"Drexel Reaches Voluntary Resolution Agreement on Title VI Investigation\", dated August 2, 2024."
      },
      "open_gates": [],
      "gate_reviews": {
        "source_availability": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The linked Drexel University statement page was reachable during Wave 17 source review.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "source_locator_specificity": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The record is tied to a specific university statement title, publisher, and publication date.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "institution_support": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The statement is published by Drexel University and describes Drexel's OCR investigation and voluntary resolution agreement.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "date_precision_support": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The record date matches the statement publication date of August 2, 2024.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "category_fit": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The statement says OCR opened an investigation and that Drexel and OCR resolved it through a voluntary resolution agreement; the category is a documentation label, not an independent legal finding.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "affected_label_boundary": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The statement describes reported harassment based on national origin, specifically shared Jewish ancestry; the stored Jewish affected-community label is bounded to that source wording.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "response_depth_classification": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The source is a direct university statement and the stored response text is limited to Drexel's described voluntary-resolution posture and actions.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "rationale_specificity": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The reviewed source supports specific rationales for category, affected-community boundary, confidence, and response depth without relying on generic metadata alone.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "overclaim_risk": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The reviewed row preserves neutral wording and does not assert endorsement, ranking, prevalence, safety scoring, severity scoring, or legal truth.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "event_id": "evt_2024_0003",
      "school_id": "lafayette_college",
      "source_family": "university_statement",
      "certification_status": "not_certified",
      "certification_basis": null,
      "not_certified_reason": "affected_label_boundary: Wave 17 source review verified statement text supporting shared Jewish ancestry, but did not verify the stored Arab affected-community label at the same source-text specificity.",
      "blocked_reason": null,
      "source_locator": {
        "locator_type": "public_statement",
        "source_id": "src_lafayette_2024_06_20_resolution",
        "publisher": "Lafayette College",
        "item_title": "Lafayette resolves OCR review",
        "published_date": "2024-06-20",
        "locator": "Lafayette College News statement titled \"Lafayette resolves OCR review\", dated June 20, 2024."
      },
      "open_gates": [
        "affected_label_boundary"
      ],
      "gate_reviews": {
        "source_availability": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The linked Lafayette College statement page was reachable during Wave 17 source review.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "source_locator_specificity": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The record is tied to a specific college news statement title, publisher, and publication date.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "institution_support": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The statement is published by Lafayette College and describes Lafayette's OCR review and voluntary resolution process.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "date_precision_support": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The record date matches the statement publication date of June 20, 2024.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "category_fit": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The statement describes an OCR review related to a discrimination complaint and a voluntary resolution; the category is a documentation label, not an independent legal finding.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "affected_label_boundary": {
          "status": "review",
          "detail": "The verified statement text supports shared Jewish ancestry in the complaint description, but this wave did not verify the stored Arab label at the same source-text specificity.",
          "required_action": "Keep the record not certified unless the affected-community label is narrowed or a source locator supporting every stored label is added."
        },
        "response_depth_classification": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The source is a direct college statement and the stored response text is limited to Lafayette's described cooperation and voluntary-resolution steps.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "rationale_specificity": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The reviewed source supports specific category, confidence, and response-depth rationales, while the affected-community boundary remains visibly unresolved.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        },
        "overclaim_risk": {
          "status": "pass",
          "detail": "The reviewed row preserves neutral wording and does not assert endorsement, ranking, prevalence, safety scoring, severity scoring, or legal truth.",
          "required_action": "No deterministic action required for this reviewed gate."
        }
      }
    }
  ]
}