{ "id": "gold_record_v1_review_packets", "snapshot_id": "snapshot_2026_06_03_10000_records", "generated_at": "2026-06-03", "status": "review_packets", "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation.", "selection_version": "gold_v1_review_priority_2026_06_16", "selection_criteria": [ "Packet-backed challenge availability is prioritized so existing public challenge work is easy to inspect.", "Records with confidence, date precision, response-depth, or rationale review needs are prioritized as review packets.", "Source-type diversity is included so review packets are not limited to a single import or source family.", "Category and state diversity are used as deterministic tie-breakers for review coverage, not as comparative claims.", "Source count is included to expose both single-source review needs and multi-source rationale review." ], "coverage_summary": { "total_records": 25, "categories": { "Harassment or threat": 9, "Other source-backed civil rights event": 1, "Vandalism": 6, "Athletic equity": 1, "Disability access": 1, "OCR complaint": 5, "Criminal investigation": 1, "Institutional response": 1 }, "source_types": { "Government dataset": 10, "Public safety notice": 3, "Annual security report": 3, "Government release": 5, "Government guidance": 1, "University statement": 3 }, "confidence": { "Medium": 22, "High": 3 }, "date_precision": { "year": 16, "month": 4, "day": 5 }, "challenge_linked": { "true": 0, "false": 25 }, "states": { "WI": 1, "CO": 2, "IL": 2, "NY": 9, "MT": 1, "ND": 1, "GA": 1, "MD": 2, "PA": 1, "CA": 1, "RI": 1, "MI": 3 } }, "selection_note": "Records are selected by deterministic review-priority criteria for packet creation; order is not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation.", "records": [ { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_3911", "event_id": "evt_2026_3911", "school_id": "academy_of_beauty_professionals", "school_name": "Academy of Beauty Professionals", "state": "WI", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2021-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_3911/", "school_url": "/schools/academy_of_beauty_professionals/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_3911", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_3911", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_3911", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2024_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2024 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2024_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2024EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell DS8076 (column INTIM_RAC21) reports an annual on-campus intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Race label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_RAC21 uses the Race bias category; no narrower racial or ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, DS8076, with year-level timing and broad Race bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety on-campus dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0450", "event_id": "evt_2026_0450", "school_id": "adams_state_university", "school_name": "Adams State University", "state": "CO", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "LGBTQ+" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0450/", "school_url": "/schools/adams_state_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0450", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0450", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0450", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell IQ960 (column INTIM_SEX23) reports an annual on-campus intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The LGBTQ+ label is retained because the source-derived record identifies the INTIM_SEX23 intimidation statistic as characterized by LGBTQ+ bias; no narrower LGBTQ+ identity is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, IQ960, with year-level timing and source-derived LGBTQ+ bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_1067", "event_id": "evt_2026_1067", "school_id": "adams_state_university", "school_name": "Adams State University", "state": "CO", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Other source-backed civil rights event", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2022-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_1067/", "school_url": "/schools/adams_state_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_1067", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_1067", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_1067", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell BQ960 (column AGG_A_RAC22) reports an annual on-campus aggravated-assault hate-crime statistic. Because the public codebook has no assault-specific category, the record is narrowed to Other source-backed civil rights event rather than Harassment or threat.", "community_rationale": "The Race label is retained because the official workbook column AGG_A_RAC22 uses the Race bias category; no narrower racial or ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, BQ960, with year-level timing and broad Race bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_2437", "event_id": "evt_2026_2437", "school_id": "adler_university", "school_name": "Adler University", "state": "IL", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Ethnicity" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_2437/", "school_url": "/schools/adler_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_2437", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_2437", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_2437", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell NQ1774 (column INTIM_ET24) reports an annual public-property intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Ethnicity label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_ET24 uses the Ethnicity bias category; no narrower ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, NQ1774, with year-level timing and broad Ethnicity bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety public-property dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0417", "event_id": "evt_2026_0417", "school_id": "albany_medical_college", "school_name": "Albany Medical College", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0417/", "school_url": "/schools/albany_medical_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0417", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0417", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0417", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell NK4108 (column INTIM_RAC24) reports annual on-campus intimidation hate-crime statistics; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Race label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_RAC24 uses the Race bias category; no narrower racial or ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, NK4108, with year-level timing and broad Race bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0060", "event_id": "evt_2026_0060", "school_id": "farmingdale_state_college", "school_name": "Farmingdale State College", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 320, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2021-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0060/", "school_url": "/schools/farmingdale_state_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0060", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0060", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0060", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_farmingdale_hate_crime_resources", "title": "Hate Crime Resources", "source_type": "Public safety notice", "source_url": "/sources/src_farmingdale_hate_crime_resources/", "external_url": "https://www.farmingdale.edu/university-police/hate-crime-res.shtml" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The stored record describes a 2021 Farmingdale State College hate-crime resources entry as vandalism/graffiti, but the current public source page has not yielded a page, table, or item locator for this reporting-year entry; the Vandalism category remains not certified until that locator is repaired.", "community_rationale": "The Race label follows the stored reporting-year entry, but the current public source page has not yielded an item-level locator that certifies the label boundary; the label remains unresolved pending a direct table or archived page locator.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence remains a provisional source-support label for the stored public-safety entry; certification is withheld because the current public locator does not expose the cited reporting-year item.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a public Clery/annual security report entry and does not independently evaluate investigative or disciplinary outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0061", "event_id": "evt_2026_0061", "school_id": "farmingdale_state_college", "school_name": "Farmingdale State College", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 320, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "LGBTQ+" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2022-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0061/", "school_url": "/schools/farmingdale_state_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0061", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0061", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0061", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_farmingdale_hate_crime_resources", "title": "Hate Crime Resources", "source_type": "Public safety notice", "source_url": "/sources/src_farmingdale_hate_crime_resources/", "external_url": "https://www.farmingdale.edu/university-police/hate-crime-res.shtml" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The stored record describes a 2022 Farmingdale State College hate-crime resources entry as vandalism/graffiti, but the current public source page has not yielded a page, table, or item locator for this reporting-year entry; the Vandalism category remains not certified until that locator is repaired.", "community_rationale": "The LGBTQ+ label follows the stored reporting-year entry, but the current public source page has not yielded an item-level locator that certifies the label boundary; the label remains unresolved pending a direct table or archived page locator.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence remains a provisional source-support label for the stored public-safety entry; certification is withheld because the current public locator does not expose the cited reporting-year item.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a public Clery/annual security report entry and does not independently evaluate investigative or disciplinary outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0062", "event_id": "evt_2026_0062", "school_id": "farmingdale_state_college", "school_name": "Farmingdale State College", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 320, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Religion" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2022-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0062/", "school_url": "/schools/farmingdale_state_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0062", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0062", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0062", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_farmingdale_hate_crime_resources", "title": "Hate Crime Resources", "source_type": "Public safety notice", "source_url": "/sources/src_farmingdale_hate_crime_resources/", "external_url": "https://www.farmingdale.edu/university-police/hate-crime-res.shtml" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The stored record describes a 2022 Farmingdale State College hate-crime resources entry as vandalism/graffiti, but the current public source page has not yielded a page, table, or item locator for this reporting-year entry; the Vandalism category remains not certified until that locator is repaired.", "community_rationale": "The Religion label follows the stored reporting-year entry, but the current public source page has not yielded an item-level locator that certifies the label boundary; the label remains unresolved pending a direct table or archived page locator.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence remains a provisional source-support label for the stored public-safety entry; certification is withheld because the current public locator does not expose the cited reporting-year item.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a public Clery/annual security report entry and does not independently evaluate investigative or disciplinary outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0040", "event_id": "evt_2026_0040", "school_id": "montana_state_university", "school_name": "Montana State University", "state": "MT", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 320, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Gender" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0040/", "school_url": "/schools/montana_state_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0040", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0040", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0040", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_montana_state_2025_asr_hate_crimes", "title": "2025 Annual Security Report", "source_type": "Annual security report", "source_url": "/sources/src_montana_state_2025_asr_hate_crimes/", "external_url": "https://www.montana.edu/clery/reports/asr/2025/index.html" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The Montana State public Annual Security Report section identifies a reporting-year 2023 on-campus student-housing vandalism incident characterized by gender bias; the Vandalism category is limited to that report wording.", "community_rationale": "The Gender label is retained because the Annual Security Report item says the vandalism incident was characterized by gender bias; no narrower gender identity or sex-based label is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one public Annual Security Report section locator for a reporting-year hate-crime entry; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a public Clery/annual security report entry and does not independently evaluate investigative or disciplinary outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0065", "event_id": "evt_2026_0065", "school_id": "queensborough_community_college", "school_name": "Queensborough Community College", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 320, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0065/", "school_url": "/schools/queensborough_community_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0065", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0065", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0065", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes", "title": "Queensborough Community College Department of Public Safety 2025 Annual Security Report", "source_type": "Annual security report", "source_url": "/sources/src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes/", "external_url": "https://www.qcc.cuny.edu/publicSafety/docs/2025-QCC-ASR.pdf" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The Queensborough Community College 2025 Annual Security Report, page 13, identifies a 2023 making-graffiti hate-crime item; the Vandalism category is limited to that graffiti wording.", "community_rationale": "The Race label is retained because the QCC report item says the graffiti evidenced racial bias; no narrower racial or ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one public Annual Security Report page locator for a reporting-year hate-crime entry; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a public Clery/annual security report entry and does not independently evaluate investigative or disciplinary outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0024", "event_id": "evt_2026_0024", "school_id": "erie_community_college", "school_name": "Erie Community College", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 240, "selection_reason": "medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Athletic equity", "affected_communities": [ "Women" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2016-03-01", "date_precision": "month", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0024/", "school_url": "/schools/erie_community_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0024", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0024", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0024", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed", "title": "What's New in OCR", "source_type": "Government release", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed/", "external_url": "https://www.ed.gov/preview-link/node/5060/e58bc9e0-17b9-483a-845a-0df68624a768" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The OCR aggregate item is headed as a Title IX athletics settlement involving Erie Community College; the Athletic equity category is limited to that public OCR item and does not independently adjudicate Title IX compliance.", "community_rationale": "The Women label is retained because the stored source-backed description concerns women’s access to athletic opportunities and the OCR item is a Title IX athletics settlement; no broader sex-equity population is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one item-level OCR aggregate locator under the March 2016 section, with month-level timing only; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes OCR's public announcement and does not independently evaluate the institution's completed response." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the month date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0022", "event_id": "evt_2026_0022", "school_id": "minot_state_university", "school_name": "Minot State University", "state": "ND", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 250, "selection_reason": "medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Disability access", "affected_communities": [ "Students with disabilities" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2015-01-01", "date_precision": "day", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0022/", "school_url": "/schools/minot_state_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0022", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0022", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0022", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed", "title": "What's New in OCR", "source_type": "Government release", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed/", "external_url": "https://www.ed.gov/preview-link/node/5060/e58bc9e0-17b9-483a-845a-0df68624a768" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The Disability access category is not internally certified because the current OCR aggregate page has not yielded an item-level locator matching the stored Minot State University disability-access record.", "community_rationale": "The Students with disabilities label is not internally certified because the current aggregate source locator has not been matched to the stored disability-access item.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence remains provisional for this record; certification is withheld until an item-level OCR locator supports the stored disability-access classification and date.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes OCR's public announcement and does not independently evaluate the institution's completed response." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the day date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0001", "event_id": "evt_2026_0001", "school_id": "emory_university", "school_name": "Emory University", "state": "GA", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 250, "selection_reason": "medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "OCR complaint", "affected_communities": [ "Muslim", "Palestinian" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2025-01-16", "date_precision": "day", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0001/", "school_url": "/schools/emory_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0001", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0001", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0001", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed", "title": "What's New in OCR", "source_type": "Government release", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed/", "external_url": "https://www.ed.gov/preview-link/node/5060/e58bc9e0-17b9-483a-845a-0df68624a768" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The OCR aggregate item is titled as a resolution of a complaint against Emory University alleging anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian discrimination; the OCR complaint category is limited to that public OCR item and does not independently adjudicate Title VI compliance.", "community_rationale": "The Muslim and Palestinian labels are retained because the OCR item title expressly says anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian discrimination; no additional affected-community labels are inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one item-level OCR aggregate locator dated January 16, 2025, with a title matching the record summary; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes OCR's public announcement and does not independently evaluate the institution's completed response." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the day date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0005", "event_id": "evt_2026_0005", "school_id": "johns_hopkins_university", "school_name": "Johns Hopkins University", "state": "MD", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 240, "selection_reason": "medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "OCR complaint", "affected_communities": [ "Jewish", "Muslim", "Palestinian", "Arab" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2025-01-01", "date_precision": "month", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0005/", "school_url": "/schools/johns_hopkins_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0005", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0005", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0005", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed", "title": "What's New in OCR", "source_type": "Government release", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed/", "external_url": "https://www.ed.gov/preview-link/node/5060/e58bc9e0-17b9-483a-845a-0df68624a768" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The OCR aggregate item identifies a Johns Hopkins University shared-ancestry resolution; the OCR complaint category is limited to that item and does not independently adjudicate Title VI compliance.", "community_rationale": "The aggregate item says shared ancestry but does not by itself certify each listed label; Jewish, Muslim, Palestinian, and Arab remain unresolved pending item-level resolution-letter review.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects an item-level OCR aggregate locator with month-level timing and unresolved affected-community label boundaries; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes OCR's public announcement and does not independently evaluate the institution's completed response." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the month date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0004", "event_id": "evt_2026_0004", "school_id": "lehigh_university", "school_name": "Lehigh University", "state": "PA", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 240, "selection_reason": "medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "OCR complaint", "affected_communities": [ "Jewish", "Muslim", "Palestinian", "Arab" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2025-01-01", "date_precision": "month", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0004/", "school_url": "/schools/lehigh_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0004", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0004", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0004", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed", "title": "What's New in OCR", "source_type": "Government release", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed/", "external_url": "https://www.ed.gov/preview-link/node/5060/e58bc9e0-17b9-483a-845a-0df68624a768" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The OCR aggregate item identifies a Lehigh University shared-ancestry resolution; the OCR complaint category is limited to that item and does not independently adjudicate Title VI compliance.", "community_rationale": "The aggregate item says shared ancestry but does not by itself certify each listed label; Jewish, Muslim, Palestinian, and Arab remain unresolved pending item-level resolution-letter review.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects an item-level OCR aggregate locator with month-level timing and unresolved affected-community label boundaries; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes OCR's public announcement and does not independently evaluate the institution's completed response." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the month date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2024_0006", "event_id": "evt_2024_0006", "school_id": "university_of_illinois_urbana_champaign", "school_name": "University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign", "state": "IL", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 180, "selection_reason": "medium or low confidence; single-source record", "category": "OCR complaint", "affected_communities": [ "Jewish", "Muslim", "Palestinian", "Arab" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2024-09-01", "date_precision": "month", "event_url": "/events/evt_2024_0006/", "school_url": "/schools/university_of_illinois_urbana_champaign/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2024_0006", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2024_0006", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2024_0006", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_2025_title_vi_hostile_environment", "title": "Resolving a Hostile Environment Under Title VI", "source_type": "Government guidance", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_2025_title_vi_hostile_environment/", "external_url": "https://www.ed.gov/media/document/resolving-hostile-environment-under-title-vi-discrimination-based-race-color-or-national-origin-including-shared-ancestry-or-ethnic-characteristics-2025" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The linked Department of Education guidance references a University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign OCR resolution, but the source is guidance rather than a direct item-specific OCR matter locator; the OCR complaint category remains not certified until a direct locator is added.", "community_rationale": "The guidance source discusses shared-ancestry discrimination context, but the current record does not have a direct item locator certifying each listed Jewish, Muslim, Palestinian, and Arab label; those label boundaries remain unresolved.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects a public government guidance source that references the matter, but certification is withheld because category fit and affected-community boundaries require a direct item-specific OCR locator.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The Department of Education guidance describes the matter as an OCR resolution connected to Title VI hostile-environment obligations." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the month date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0078", "event_id": "evt_2026_0078", "school_id": "san_jose_state_university", "school_name": "San Jose State University", "state": "CA", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 138, "selection_reason": "single-source record", "category": "Criminal investigation", "affected_communities": [ "Asian" ], "confidence": "High", "date": "2022-06-17", "date_precision": "day", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0078/", "school_url": "/schools/san_jose_state_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0078", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0078", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0078", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_sjsu_2022_anti_asian_hate_crime", "title": "Anti-Asian Hate Crime on SJSU Campus", "source_type": "University statement", "source_url": "/sources/src_sjsu_2022_anti_asian_hate_crime/", "external_url": "https://www.sjsu.edu/diversity/office/comms/archive/20220617_anti-asian_hate_crime_on_sjsu_campus.php" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The linked SJSU statement says a campus SJSUAlert described the matter as an anti-Asian hate crime attack and says the suspect was arrested; the record uses \"Criminal investigation\" to summarize that public statement without independently determining legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The affected-community label is limited to Asian because the linked SJSU statement says the attack targeted a male of Asian descent and discusses anti-Asian hate.", "confidence_rationale": "High confidence is limited to source-to-record support because the record is based on a live, item-specific SJSU Office of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion statement dated June 17, 2022; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The university statement describes outreach to AAPI campus groups, coordination with University Police, and support resources; this record does not independently evaluate investigative outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the day date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0080", "event_id": "evt_2026_0080", "school_id": "towson_university", "school_name": "Towson University", "state": "MD", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 138, "selection_reason": "single-source record", "category": "Institutional response", "affected_communities": [ "Black" ], "confidence": "High", "date": "2016-11-16", "date_precision": "day", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0080/", "school_url": "/schools/towson_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0080", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0080", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0080", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_towson_2016_hate_bias_update", "title": "Hate/bias investigation update", "source_type": "University statement", "source_url": "/sources/src_towson_2016_hate_bias_update/", "external_url": "https://www.towson.edu/news/2016/hatebiasupdate.html" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The stored description says Towson University issued a public hate/bias investigation update, but the linked university URL redirects away from the cited item; the Institutional response category remains blocked until a direct or archived source locator is repaired.", "community_rationale": "The Black label follows the stored description of the Towson update, but the record remains blocked because the cited source locator currently redirects away from the item needed to verify source wording.", "confidence_rationale": "High confidence cannot be treated as certification while the cited Towson source redirects; the record remains blocked pending a direct or archived university source locator.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The university update states that campus police identified the non-affiliate and issued a denial of access to campus; this record summarizes that public statement without independently evaluating the investigation." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the day date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2024_0001", "event_id": "evt_2024_0001", "school_id": "brown_university", "school_name": "Brown University", "state": "RI", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 138, "selection_reason": "single-source record", "category": "OCR complaint", "affected_communities": [ "Jewish", "Muslim" ], "confidence": "High", "date": "2024-07-08", "date_precision": "day", "event_url": "/events/evt_2024_0001/", "school_url": "/schools/brown_university/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2024_0001", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2024_0001", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2024_0001", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_brown_2024_07_08_resolution", "title": "Brown reaches agreement that resolves OCR complaint alleging antisemitism", "source_type": "University statement", "source_url": "/sources/src_brown_2024_07_08_resolution/", "external_url": "https://www.brown.edu/news/2024-07-08/resolution-agreement" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The linked Brown statement says the U.S. Department of Education Office for Civil Rights announced a voluntary resolution agreement connected to a complaint alleging antisemitism; the OCR complaint category summarizes that public statement without independently deciding Title VI compliance.", "community_rationale": "The Jewish label is supported by the Brown statement's references to antisemitism. The Muslim label is supported by Brown's quoted OCR language referencing anti-Muslim hate. Palestinian and Arab labels were removed because this source page did not name them directly.", "confidence_rationale": "High confidence is limited to source-to-record support because the record is based on a live, item-specific Brown University statement dated July 8, 2024; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: Brown said it agreed to continue nondiscrimination training, investigator training, policy clarification, and reporting commitments under the OCR resolution agreement." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the day date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_1922", "event_id": "evt_2026_1922", "school_id": "albert_einstein_college_of_medicine", "school_name": "Albert Einstein College of Medicine", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Religion" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_1922/", "school_url": "/schools/albert_einstein_college_of_medicine/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_1922", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_1922", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_1922", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell IP7638 (column INTIM_REL23) reports an annual on-campus intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Religion label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_REL23 uses the Religion bias category; no specific religious community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, IP7638, with year-level timing and broad Religion bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_2553", "event_id": "evt_2026_2553", "school_id": "albert_einstein_college_of_medicine", "school_name": "Albert Einstein College of Medicine", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Religion" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_2553/", "school_url": "/schools/albert_einstein_college_of_medicine/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_2553", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_2553", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_2553", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell NL7638 (column INTIM_REL24) reports an annual public-property intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Religion label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_REL24 uses the Religion bias category; no specific religious community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, NL7638, with year-level timing and broad Religion bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety public-property dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0243", "event_id": "evt_2026_0243", "school_id": "albion_college", "school_name": "Albion College", "state": "MI", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0243/", "school_url": "/schools/albion_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0243", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0243", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0243", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell NK3083 (column INTIM_RAC24) reports an annual on-campus intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Race label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_RAC24 uses the Race bias category; no narrower racial or ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, NK3083, with year-level timing and broad Race bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0878", "event_id": "evt_2026_0878", "school_id": "albion_college", "school_name": "Albion College", "state": "MI", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Students with disabilities" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0878/", "school_url": "/schools/albion_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0878", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0878", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0878", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell IT3083 (column INTIM_DIS23) reports an annual on-campus intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Students with disabilities label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_DIS23 uses the Disability bias category; no individual disability status or narrower subgroup is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, IT3083, with year-level timing and Disability bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_1156", "event_id": "evt_2026_1156", "school_id": "albion_college", "school_name": "Albion College", "state": "MI", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 350, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record; government dataset source basis", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2022-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_1156/", "school_url": "/schools/albion_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_1156", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_1156", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_1156", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "title": "Campus Safety and Security Data Analysis Cutting Tool 2025 Excel data files", "source_type": "Government dataset", "source_url": "/sources/src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files/", "external_url": "https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/api/dataFiles/file?fileName=Crime2025EXCEL.zip" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The official Department of Education workbook cell DS3083 (column INTIM_RAC22) reports an annual on-campus intimidation hate-crime statistic; the Harassment or threat category is limited to that structured intimidation field and does not independently characterize severity or legal outcome.", "community_rationale": "The Race label is retained because the official workbook column INTIM_RAC22 uses the Race bias category; no narrower racial or ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one official Department of Education workbook cell, DS3083, with year-level timing and broad Race bias-category metadata; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a Department of Education Clery/campus-safety dataset cell and does not independently evaluate investigative, disciplinary, or institutional response outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." }, { "id": "gold_v1_evt_2026_0066", "event_id": "evt_2026_0066", "school_id": "queensborough_community_college", "school_name": "Queensborough Community College", "state": "NY", "status": "gold_v1_review_packet", "review_score": 320, "selection_reason": "year-level date precision; medium or low confidence; limited or missing stored response text; single-source record", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0066/", "school_url": "/schools/queensborough_community_college/", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0066", "correction_url": "/submit/?type=correction&record_id=evt_2026_0066", "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0066", "source_basis": [ { "id": "src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes", "title": "Queensborough Community College Department of Public Safety 2025 Annual Security Report", "source_type": "Annual security report", "source_url": "/sources/src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes/", "external_url": "https://www.qcc.cuny.edu/publicSafety/docs/2025-QCC-ASR.pdf" } ], "rationale_packet": { "classification_rationale": "The Queensborough Community College 2025 Annual Security Report, page 13, identifies a 2024 making-graffiti hate-crime item; the Vandalism category is limited to that graffiti wording.", "community_rationale": "The Race label is retained because the QCC report item says the graffiti evidenced racial bias; no narrower racial or ethnic community is inferred.", "confidence_rationale": "Medium confidence reflects one public Annual Security Report page locator for a reporting-year hate-crime entry; it is not a severity score, prevalence estimate, or legal finding.", "response_note": "Stored institutional response text: The record summarizes a public Clery/annual security report entry and does not independently evaluate investigative or disciplinary outcomes." }, "review_questions": [ "Does the linked public source support the current category language?", "Do the affected-community labels match the public source text at the right level of specificity?", "Does the confidence rationale describe source support without implying severity, prevalence, or legal truth?", "Is the stored institutional response text current, public, and bounded to what the source says?", "Does the year date precision match what the source supports?" ], "public_claim_limit": "This gold v1 review packet is not outside validation, not a ranking, not a safety score, not a severity score, not a prevalence estimate, not a legal finding, not an endorsement, and not external validation." } ] }