{ "id": "external_review_packet_v1", "snapshot_id": "snapshot_2026_06_03_10000_records", "generated_at": "2026-06-03", "status": "public_external_review_packet", "method": "Formal public evidence dossier generated only from Gold v1 records whose internal certification gates currently pass. It packages source-to-record review steps, challenge templates, known limits, and batch-scaling guidance; it is not outside validation, endorsement, ranking, prevalence measurement, safety scoring, severity scoring, or legal adjudication.", "public_claim_limit": "This packet may be used for source-to-record review. It must not be described as third-party review, external validation, institutional quality judgment, school ranking, safety scoring, severity scoring, prevalence measurement, endorsement, or legal finding.", "selection_standard": { "source": "data/gold-v1-certification-status.json", "rule": "Include only records with certification_status=certified; exclude blocked and not_certified records.", "max_records": 25, "selected_records": 17 }, "totals": { "records": 17, "certified_gold_v1_available": 17, "excluded_not_certified_gold_v1": 7, "excluded_blocked_gold_v1": 1 }, "review_batches": [ { "id": "gold_v1_external_review_batch_001", "label": "Gold v1 External Review Batch 001", "batch_size": 17, "record_ids": [ "evt_2024_0001", "evt_2026_0001", "evt_2026_0024", "evt_2026_0040", "evt_2026_0065", "evt_2026_0066", "evt_2026_0078", "evt_2026_0243", "evt_2026_0417", "evt_2026_0450", "evt_2026_0878", "evt_2026_1067", "evt_2026_1156", "evt_2026_1922", "evt_2026_2437", "evt_2026_2553", "evt_2026_3911" ], "review_standard": "Each record must be rechecked from public source locator to database fields before any reviewer conclusion is accepted.", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2024_0001%2Cevt_2026_0001%2Cevt_2026_0024%2Cevt_2026_0040%2Cevt_2026_0065%2Cevt_2026_0066%2Cevt_2026_0078%2Cevt_2026_0243%2Cevt_2026_0417%2Cevt_2026_0450%2Cevt_2026_0878%2Cevt_2026_1067%2Cevt_2026_1156%2Cevt_2026_1922%2Cevt_2026_2437%2Cevt_2026_2553%2Cevt_2026_3911" }, { "id": "review_debt_batching_rule", "label": "Whole-database Batch Rule", "batch_size": 25, "record_ids": [], "review_standard": "Scale the remaining review debt in source-family batches from data/review-debt-ledger.json. Do not call a batch certified until every record in that batch clears the same source locator, date, category, affected-label, response-depth, and rationale gates." } ], "challenge_templates": [ { "id": "source_locator_challenge", "label": "Source Locator Challenge", "prompt": "Does the linked source URL and locator land on the exact source item, table, page, workbook cell, or document section supporting the record?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "source URL reviewed", "current locator", "specific missing or stronger locator", "proposed correction" ] }, { "id": "category_challenge", "label": "Category Challenge", "prompt": "Does the source wording support the stored category without implying a stronger legal or severity conclusion?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "source passage or table field", "current category", "proposed category or limit note" ] }, { "id": "affected_label_challenge", "label": "Affected-Community Label Challenge", "prompt": "Does the source support each affected-community label at the stored level of specificity?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "source wording", "current label", "label to remove, narrow, or qualify" ] }, { "id": "date_precision_challenge", "label": "Date Precision Challenge", "prompt": "Does the source support the stored day, month, or year precision?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "source date field or item date", "current date precision", "proposed precision" ] }, { "id": "response_depth_challenge", "label": "Response-Depth Challenge", "prompt": "Does the response field distinguish direct institutional response, agency-described action, limited note, and no public response found?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "source response text", "current response-depth label", "proposed label or wording" ] }, { "id": "rationale_specificity_challenge", "label": "Rationale Specificity Challenge", "prompt": "Are classification, community, and confidence rationales specific to the linked public source?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "rationale field", "source support", "proposed source-bounded rationale" ] }, { "id": "inclusion_challenge", "label": "Inclusion Challenge", "prompt": "Does the record satisfy the project inclusion rule for public-source campus civil-rights documentation?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "public source reviewed", "inclusion concern", "proposed keep/remove/qualify outcome" ] }, { "id": "counterevidence_challenge", "label": "Counterevidence Challenge", "prompt": "Does another public source materially contradict, narrow, update, or clarify the current record?", "required_evidence": [ "record ID", "counterevidence URL", "conflicting field", "proposed correction or note" ] } ], "known_limits": { "unresolved_records": { "blocked": 1, "high_review_debt": 3908, "medium_review_debt": 74, "not_certified_gold_v1": 7, "blocked_gold_v1": 1 }, "source_family_counts": { "ed_campus_safety_dataset": 9845, "ocr_or_ed_release": 88, "annual_security_report": 46, "government_release": 9, "university_statement": 6, "campus_public_safety_notice": 4, "government_case_or_letter": 1, "government_guidance": 1 }, "top_issue_counts": { "missing_explicit_rationales": 3884, "thin_response_note": 3882, "year_precision_public_use_limit": 3882, "dataset_cell_locator_needed": 3835, "broad_affected_community_label": 2838, "category_may_be_too_generic_for_offense": 537, "generic_or_generated_rationale": 91, "page_table_locator_needed": 47, "aggregated_source_item_locator_needed": 24, "day_precision_from_mixed_date_source": 24, "multi_community_label_boundary_review": 10, "guidance_source_category_fit_review": 1 }, "note": "Known limits are review queues and unresolved source-to-record checks, not findings that records are false, severe, representative, complete, or externally reviewed." }, "records": [ { "event_id": "evt_2024_0001", "school_id": "brown_university", "date": "2024-07-08", "date_precision": "day", "category": "OCR complaint", "affected_communities": [ "Jewish", "Muslim" ], "confidence": "High", "source_ids": [ "src_brown_2024_07_08_resolution" ], "source_types": [ "University statement" ], "source_family": "university_statement", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "direct_institutional_response", "source_locators": [], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2024_0001/ and the source index entries: src_brown_2024_07_08_resolution.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: no locator stored; do not treat this as a certified external packet row.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2024_0001", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2024_0001", "event_url": "/events/evt_2024_0001/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0001", "school_id": "emory_university", "date": "2025-01-16", "date_precision": "day", "category": "OCR complaint", "affected_communities": [ "Muslim", "Palestinian" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed" ], "source_types": [ "Government release" ], "source_family": "ocr_or_ed_release", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed", "locator_type": "aggregate_item", "locator": "What's New in OCR item dated January 16, 2025: \"U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights Announces Resolution of Complaint Against Emory University in Georgia Alleging Anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian Discrimination.\"", "item_date": "2025-01-16", "item_date_precision": "day", "item_label": "Emory University anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian discrimination resolution item", "review_note": "Located in the OCR aggregate page as a dated item with linked resolution letter and agreement." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For OCR or government release records, verify the exact item title/date and distinguish agency-described action from direct institutional response." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0001/ and the source index entries: src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed: aggregate_item / What's New in OCR item dated January 16, 2025: \"U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights Announces Resolution of Complaint Against Emory University in Georgia Alleging Anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian Discrimination.\".", "For OCR/government release evidence, verify the item date, item title, and whether the source describes an agency action or direct institutional response.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0001", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0001", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0001/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0024", "school_id": "erie_community_college", "date": "2016-03-01", "date_precision": "month", "category": "Athletic equity", "affected_communities": [ "Women" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed" ], "source_types": [ "Government release" ], "source_family": "ocr_or_ed_release", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed", "locator_type": "aggregate_item", "locator": "What's New in OCR item headed \"Settlement Reached on Title IX Athletics Probe at Buffalo's Erie Community College\" under the March 2016 section.", "item_date": "2016-03-01", "item_date_precision": "month", "item_label": "Erie Community College Title IX athletics settlement item", "review_note": "The public aggregate page gives a March 2016 month heading for this item; the previous day-level 2013 date was not supported by the current aggregate locator." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For OCR or government release records, verify the exact item title/date and distinguish agency-described action from direct institutional response." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0024/ and the source index entries: src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_ocr_whats_new_shared_ancestry_higher_ed: aggregate_item / What's New in OCR item headed \"Settlement Reached on Title IX Athletics Probe at Buffalo's Erie Community College\" under the March 2016 section..", "For OCR/government release evidence, verify the item date, item title, and whether the source describes an agency action or direct institutional response.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0024", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0024", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0024/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0040", "school_id": "montana_state_university", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Gender" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_montana_state_2025_asr_hate_crimes" ], "source_types": [ "Annual security report" ], "source_family": "annual_security_report", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_montana_state_2025_asr_hate_crimes", "locator_type": "document_section", "locator": "2025 Annual Security Report HTML section \"HATE CRIMES BY CATEGORY AND BIAS\", Reporting Year 2023, item \"One on-campus student housing vandalism incident, characterized by gender bias.\"", "section": "HATE CRIMES BY CATEGORY AND BIAS", "item_label": "Reporting Year 2023 gender-bias student-housing vandalism item", "review_note": "Located in the public HTML annual security report text under the hate-crimes category-and-bias section." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For ASR records, verify the page, table, statistic label, reporting year, and offense/bias-characterization field." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0040/ and the source index entries: src_montana_state_2025_asr_hate_crimes.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_montana_state_2025_asr_hate_crimes: document_section / 2025 Annual Security Report HTML section \"HATE CRIMES BY CATEGORY AND BIAS\", Reporting Year 2023, item \"One on-campus student housing vandalism incident, characterized by gender bias.\".", "For ASR evidence, verify the cited page/table/section and the exact row/column or statistic label.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0040", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0040", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0040/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0065", "school_id": "queensborough_community_college", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes" ], "source_types": [ "Annual security report" ], "source_family": "annual_security_report", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes", "locator_type": "page_table", "locator": "2025-QCC-ASR.pdf, PDF page 13, \"Hate Crime and Bias Related Incidents\" narrative, 2023 item for making graffiti evidencing racial bias on campus.", "page": "13", "section": "Hate Crime and Bias Related Incidents", "item_label": "2023 making graffiti evidencing racial bias on campus", "review_note": "Located by PDF text extraction from the public 2025 QCC Annual Security Report." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For ASR records, verify the page, table, statistic label, reporting year, and offense/bias-characterization field." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0065/ and the source index entries: src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes: page_table / 2025-QCC-ASR.pdf, PDF page 13, \"Hate Crime and Bias Related Incidents\" narrative, 2023 item for making graffiti evidencing racial bias on campus..", "For ASR evidence, verify the cited page/table/section and the exact row/column or statistic label.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0065", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0065", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0065/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0066", "school_id": "queensborough_community_college", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Vandalism", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes" ], "source_types": [ "Annual security report" ], "source_family": "annual_security_report", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes", "locator_type": "page_table", "locator": "2025-QCC-ASR.pdf, PDF page 13, \"Hate Crime and Bias Related Incidents\" narrative, 2024 item for making graffiti evidencing racial bias on campus.", "page": "13", "section": "Hate Crime and Bias Related Incidents", "item_label": "2024 making graffiti evidencing racial bias on campus", "review_note": "Located by PDF text extraction from the public 2025 QCC Annual Security Report." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For ASR records, verify the page, table, statistic label, reporting year, and offense/bias-characterization field." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0066/ and the source index entries: src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_qcc_2025_asr_hate_crimes: page_table / 2025-QCC-ASR.pdf, PDF page 13, \"Hate Crime and Bias Related Incidents\" narrative, 2024 item for making graffiti evidencing racial bias on campus..", "For ASR evidence, verify the cited page/table/section and the exact row/column or statistic label.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0066", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0066", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0066/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0078", "school_id": "san_jose_state_university", "date": "2022-06-17", "date_precision": "day", "category": "Criminal investigation", "affected_communities": [ "Asian" ], "confidence": "High", "source_ids": [ "src_sjsu_2022_anti_asian_hate_crime" ], "source_types": [ "University statement" ], "source_family": "university_statement", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "direct_institutional_response", "source_locators": [], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0078/ and the source index entries: src_sjsu_2022_anti_asian_hate_crime.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: no locator stored; do not treat this as a certified external packet row.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0078", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0078", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0078/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0243", "school_id": "albion_college", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 3083 > column INTIM_RAC24 > cell NK3083 (value 1)", "workbook": "Oncampushate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 3083, "column": "INTIM_RAC24", "cell": "NK3083", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0243/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 3083 > column INTIM_RAC24 > cell NK3083 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0243", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0243", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0243/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0417", "school_id": "albany_medical_college", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 4108 > column INTIM_RAC24 > cell NK4108 (value 2)", "workbook": "Oncampushate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 4108, "column": "INTIM_RAC24", "cell": "NK4108", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0417/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 4108 > column INTIM_RAC24 > cell NK4108 (value 2).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0417", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0417", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0417/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0450", "school_id": "adams_state_university", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "LGBTQ+" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 960 > column INTIM_SEX23 > cell IQ960 (value 1)", "workbook": "Oncampushate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 960, "column": "INTIM_SEX23", "cell": "IQ960", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0450/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 960 > column INTIM_SEX23 > cell IQ960 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0450", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0450", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0450/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_0878", "school_id": "albion_college", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Students with disabilities" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 3083 > column INTIM_DIS23 > cell IT3083 (value 1)", "workbook": "Oncampushate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 3083, "column": "INTIM_DIS23", "cell": "IT3083", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_0878/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 3083 > column INTIM_DIS23 > cell IT3083 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_0878", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_0878", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_0878/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_1067", "school_id": "adams_state_university", "date": "2022-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Other source-backed civil rights event", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 960 > column AGG_A_RAC22 > cell BQ960 (value 1)", "workbook": "Oncampushate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 960, "column": "AGG_A_RAC22", "cell": "BQ960", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_1067/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 960 > column AGG_A_RAC22 > cell BQ960 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_1067", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_1067", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_1067/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_1156", "school_id": "albion_college", "date": "2022-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 3083 > column INTIM_RAC22 > cell DS3083 (value 1)", "workbook": "Oncampushate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 3083, "column": "INTIM_RAC22", "cell": "DS3083", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_1156/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 3083 > column INTIM_RAC22 > cell DS3083 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_1156", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_1156", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_1156/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_1922", "school_id": "albert_einstein_college_of_medicine", "date": "2023-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Religion" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 7638 > column INTIM_REL23 > cell IP7638 (value 1)", "workbook": "Oncampushate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 7638, "column": "INTIM_REL23", "cell": "IP7638", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_1922/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 7638 > column INTIM_REL23 > cell IP7638 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_1922", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_1922", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_1922/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_2437", "school_id": "adler_university", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Ethnicity" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Publicpropertyhate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 1774 > column INTIM_ET24 > cell NQ1774 (value 1)", "workbook": "Publicpropertyhate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 1774, "column": "INTIM_ET24", "cell": "NQ1774", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_2437/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Publicpropertyhate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 1774 > column INTIM_ET24 > cell NQ1774 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_2437", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_2437", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_2437/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_2553", "school_id": "albert_einstein_college_of_medicine", "date": "2024-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Religion" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Publicpropertyhate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 7638 > column INTIM_REL24 > cell NL7638 (value 1)", "workbook": "Publicpropertyhate222324.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 7638, "column": "INTIM_REL24", "cell": "NL7638", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_2553/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2025_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2025EXCEL.zip > Publicpropertyhate222324.xlsx > sheet1 row 7638 > column INTIM_REL24 > cell NL7638 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_2553", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_2553", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_2553/" }, { "event_id": "evt_2026_3911", "school_id": "academy_of_beauty_professionals", "date": "2021-01-01", "date_precision": "year", "category": "Harassment or threat", "affected_communities": [ "Race" ], "confidence": "Medium", "source_ids": [ "src_ed_campus_safety_2024_hate_crime_data_files" ], "source_types": [ "Government dataset" ], "source_family": "ed_campus_safety_dataset", "gold_v1_certification_status": "certified", "debt_status": "lower_priority_review_debt", "response_depth": "limited_public_response_note", "source_locators": [ { "source_id": "src_ed_campus_safety_2024_hate_crime_data_files", "locator_type": "workbook_cell", "locator": "Crime2024EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate212223.xlsx > sheet1 row 8076 > column INTIM_RAC21 > cell DS8076 (value 1)", "workbook": "Oncampushate212223.xlsx", "sheet": "sheet1", "row": 8076, "column": "INTIM_RAC21", "cell": "DS8076", "review_note": "Matched against the official Department of Education Campus Safety and Security Excel workbook by school name and nonzero hate-crime statistic cell." } ], "source_checklist": [ "Open the event page and record ID before inspecting sources.", "Open each linked public source in a separate tab.", "Confirm the source publisher, title, publication date, and URL match the source index.", "Use the stored source locator before accepting any record field.", "Compare school, date precision, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and confidence rationale against the source.", "Record any correction as a source-backed challenge, not as an endorsement or broad campus judgment.", "For dataset records, verify workbook, sheet, row, column, and cell locator before quoting the record.", "Treat year-level data as reporting-year data unless the source provides an exact incident date." ], "replication_steps": [ "Open /events/evt_2026_3911/ and the source index entries: src_ed_campus_safety_2024_hate_crime_data_files.", "Confirm the event record hash in data/events.json after running npm run hash:data.", "Open the stored source locator: src_ed_campus_safety_2024_hate_crime_data_files: workbook_cell / Crime2024EXCEL.zip > Oncampushate212223.xlsx > sheet1 row 8076 > column INTIM_RAC21 > cell DS8076 (value 1).", "For workbook evidence, verify workbook name, sheet, row, column, and cell before relying on the record.", "Compare the source locator to the stored school, date, category, affected-community labels, response-depth label, legal/procedural status, and rationale fields.", "Open data/gold-v1-certification-status.json and confirm every gate for this record is pass/certified.", "If any field is unsupported, file a challenge or correction with source URL, field name, current value, and proposed source-bounded value." ], "challenge_url": "/challenge/?record=evt_2026_3911", "workspace_url": "/research-workspace/?record_ids=evt_2026_3911", "event_url": "/events/evt_2026_3911/" } ] }