{
  "snapshot_id": "snapshot_2026_06_03_10000_records",
  "generated_at": "2026-06-03",
  "method": "Challenge standards define what public counterevidence can change a Campus Evidence Lab record. They are correction standards, not external audit, endorsement, ranking, severity scoring, safety scoring, or prevalence measurement.",
  "standards": [
    {
      "id": "category_challenge",
      "label": "Category challenge",
      "applies_when": "The assigned event category may be broader or different from what the linked public source supports.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A public source showing the event belongs in a narrower or different Campus Evidence Lab category.",
        "A public source showing the current category relies on language not present in the source basis."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "A disagreement with the category without a public source.",
        "A preference for different terminology that does not change the source-supported meaning."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "category_changed",
        "category_narrowed",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "category",
        "classification_rationale",
        "limitations"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "A category challenge is about source fit, not incident severity or institutional quality."
    },
    {
      "id": "affected_community_challenge",
      "label": "Affected-community challenge",
      "applies_when": "Affected-community labels may be broader than the public source supports.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A public source identifying a narrower affected community.",
        "A public source showing that a listed community is not supported by the record basis."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "A claim that the event affected a different group without public support.",
        "A general objection to group labels without evidence tied to the record."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "community_label_changed",
        "community_label_narrowed",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "affected_communities",
        "community_rationale",
        "limitations"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "Affected-community labels describe source-backed record metadata, not prevalence or campus climate."
    },
    {
      "id": "confidence_challenge",
      "label": "Confidence challenge",
      "applies_when": "The confidence label may not match the current source basis or rationale.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A public source adding independent support for the same record.",
        "A public source or source limitation showing current confidence should be lower."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "A severity argument.",
        "An assertion that a record is important without source-basis evidence."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "confidence_raised",
        "confidence_lowered",
        "confidence_rationale_updated",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "confidence",
        "confidence_rationale",
        "field_support",
        "limitations"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "Confidence describes source support, not truth, severity, or legal findings."
    },
    {
      "id": "date_precision_challenge",
      "label": "Date-precision challenge",
      "applies_when": "The date precision may be more exact or less exact than the public source supports.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A public source identifying the exact day, month, or only year supported by the record.",
        "A public source showing the current date refers to publication, resolution, or reporting period rather than event timing."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "A date guess from secondary discussion.",
        "A date from a non-public source that cannot be reviewed."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "date_changed",
        "date_precision_narrowed",
        "date_precision_broadened",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "date",
        "date_precision",
        "description",
        "limitations"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "Date precision is a source-support field, not a claim that the underlying event occurred on a more exact date than sources allow."
    },
    {
      "id": "institutional_response_challenge",
      "label": "Institutional-response challenge",
      "applies_when": "The institutional response text or response-depth label may be incomplete, generic, or overstated.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A direct public institutional statement or archived page.",
        "A public agency document describing institutional action.",
        "A public source showing no public institutional response was found after reasonable search."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "Private correspondence.",
        "A general belief that the institution must have responded."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "response_text_updated",
        "response_depth_changed",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "institutional_response",
        "response_depth",
        "response_date",
        "limitations"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "Response depth describes public documentation, not whether an institution acted appropriately."
    },
    {
      "id": "legal_status_challenge",
      "label": "Legal-status challenge",
      "applies_when": "Legal, OCR, procedural, or administrative status may be outdated, imprecise, or too broad.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A public docket, OCR page, agency release, court filing, or institutional document updating status.",
        "A public source showing that the current status text should be narrower."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "A legal conclusion without a public source.",
        "A news summary that does not update the procedural status."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "legal_status_updated",
        "legal_status_narrowed",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "legal_status",
        "description",
        "limitations"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "Legal-status text is procedural metadata, not a legal finding by Campus Evidence Lab."
    },
    {
      "id": "source_sufficiency_challenge",
      "label": "Source-sufficiency challenge",
      "applies_when": "The record may need another source, a better locator, or narrower language.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A better public URL, archived copy, source page, data file locator, or source excerpt pointer.",
        "A public source showing current language should be narrowed."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "A broken-link report without an alternate public locator.",
        "A source that does not refer to the same record."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "source_added",
        "source_locator_updated",
        "language_narrowed",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "source_ids",
        "description",
        "field_support",
        "limitations"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "Source sufficiency is about reviewability of the record, not whether the underlying event is more or less serious."
    },
    {
      "id": "inclusion_challenge",
      "label": "Inclusion challenge",
      "applies_when": "The record may not satisfy the public-source inclusion rule or may be outside current scope.",
      "acceptable_counterevidence": [
        "A public source showing the record is outside the current civil-rights or public-source scope.",
        "A public correction showing the source basis does not support inclusion."
      ],
      "insufficient_counterevidence": [
        "A request to remove an uncomfortable record without source-basis evidence.",
        "A disagreement with public reporting alone."
      ],
      "possible_outcomes": [
        "record_removed",
        "record_archived",
        "record_limited",
        "closed_no_change",
        "needs_more_evidence"
      ],
      "fields_that_may_change": [
        "verification_status",
        "limitations",
        "changelog"
      ],
      "no_overclaiming_warning": "Inclusion means the record fits current source and scope rules; it is not a finding of legal truth."
    }
  ]
}